2009 Toyota Highlander Engines

Used and remanufactured engines that fit the 2009 Toyota Highlander. Each unit below is matched to this vehicle, warranty-backed, and shipped with freight quoted at checkout from Ironclad.

Available Engines (3)

  • e-r_178130

    Price
    $8,026.66
    Engine:
    3.5L
    Condition:
    remanufactured

  • Used Engine

    Price
    $2,009.00
    Engine:
    3.5L
    Mileage:
    155,877
    Condition:
    used

  • Used Engine

    Price
    $1,120.00
    Engine:
    3.3L
    Mileage:
    156,959
    Condition:
    used

Other Toyota Highlander Years

2009 Toyota Highlander Engine Market Context

Is replacing the engine worth it?

Vehicle value (mid-size suv):
$3,500 – $4,000
Repair makes sense under:
≈$1,680

Rule of thumb: a engine replacement is usually worth it when the installed cost stays under 48% of what the 2009 Toyota Highlander is worth — most units below beat that comfortably.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it worth repairing or replacing the engine on a 2009 Toyota Highlander?

As a general rule of thumb, an engine replacement on a 2009 Toyota Highlander (mid-size suv segment, vehicle value roughly $3,500–$4,000) is usually worth it when the installed cost stays under about $1,680 — roughly 48% of what the vehicle is worth.

What years of Toyota Highlander does an remanufactured or new engine fit?

Based on vendor-verified fitment data across 18 listed engines, remanufactured and new engines for this model cover the 2001–2021 model years. Always confirm your exact VIN or engine/transmission code before ordering, since fitment can vary by submodel or engine.